Those are some valid points, however, Dutch always had a God complex and demanded everyone have “faith” in him. It's clearly visible to both the player and Arthur that she pulled a knife on. “Who the Hell is Leviticus Cornwall?”. Micah was a rat, an asshole and the evil whisper in Dutch's ear, but Dutch did actions that were, in the moment, and not preplanned. 251K subscribers in the RDR2 community. According to some theories, he may have mental health issues. He serves to highlight Dutch's descent into madness and his lack of prominence shows how dutch is grasping at any straws that he can get his hands on. Deaths [] Cornwall train guards - Killed by the Van der Linde gang while trying to defend the train during the robbery. She was eventually murdered by notorious gang leader Colm O'Driscoll, igniting a feud began between the O'Driscoll and Van der Linde gangs which would last for years. Dutch is no different than Jim Jones, L. Cornwall robs his employees of their time and their money, because as we see demonstrated by Annesburg they are all underpaid. Red Dead Redemption 2's Dutch is one of the most well-spoken characters in the game and appears reading books by his tent. Dutch is a key character in the game and cannot be killed. He even said that. If he ever Escapes. Leviticus Cornwall is shown to be an irritable and arrogant man. Dutch knew what he was doing and the plan would have worked. That’s interesting because I was playing the part last night when Dutch killed Cornwall, gunfight ensues, and they steal horses from the wagon. He'll stab you in the back, but if you didn't expect it to come it's your own fault. l): "Dutch kills Cornwall #CapCut". Doing the trolley station robbery (caused him to be a idiot) 22. You observed that in every hiest with Dutch something is going wrong. The same goes for when Dutch chooses to call doubting Arthur or John "son" at various points. It's the larger red circle on your map. Run to the front of the train to find the Engine. Cleet - Hung by John Marston or shot by Sadie Adler. Micah was the only one that agreed with Dutch no matter what. 8. Even my best friend here, he thinks I'm crazy, and like this. If he ever Escapes. It’s a pipe, usually found in Dutch’s mouth, try giving it to him. Hide behind some boxes by the docks before Cornwall and Milton’s boat arrives. " "When I'm gone, they'll just find another monster. She is mentioned in both Redemption games; first by the strange man when talking to John Marston in RDR and then by John in RDR2 (which is relevant). Arthur meets Dutch and Micah in Annesburg where they are planning to confront Cornwall. The thing is this wasn't Dutch's gang it was Dutch and Hosea's gang. Exactly. Reddit community for discussing and sharing content relating to Red Dead Redemption 2 & Red Dead Online. Jenny (Confirmed Fate) - Died before Colter. He wants to lay low and continue west, and not anger a powerful oil baron by robbing his train. The constant intensity of the pressure of being on the run hunted by the law and other gangs and leading a pack of some of the most absolutely formidable and violent gunslingers in the West would have taken a constant and. Reddit community for discussing and sharing content relating to Red Dead Redemption… Ever since the incident, Arthur wears his father’s hat. He’ll meet you outside, along with Jack. He was heating things between the pinkertons and the gang so that they get caught and he could escape. They have to, because they have to justify their wages. Not because he finally realized Arthur was right or out of his love for John. The Pinkertons are reckless and tons of federal agents killed because of it. He is also incredibly vindictive towards the Van der Linde gang for consistently robbi…TyBuck • 3 yr. Mr. Dutch van der Linde : I'm undone already. If Dutch really wanted that Blackwater money he could have gotten it, but by getting it he would have lost everyone. The Sheep and the Goats is a mission in Red Dead Redemption 2. #rdr2 #memes#gamingDutch didn't seem to really care about Hosea dying. Issue. After Dutch robs his train, Leviticus Cornwall hires Milton. Made enemies with the Gray's and Braithworths in Rhodes. When the Pinkertons found the camp (perhaps due to Micah’s information), Abigail and Jack would’ve pretty much been the only ones there. Dutch mentions in Ch1 that Arthur and Hosea had already begun doubting him, so he was already losing faith in their loyalty right from the start of the game. Its true that Micah was really just a rival for most of the game but was the villain for chapter 6 and the 2nd part of the epilogue but the story does end with him getting killed by John. Timeline wise what probably happened is the Gang robbed the train, Cornwall hired the Pinkertons to catch who did it, Pinkertons begin investigating the surrounding area, immediately hear of people who sound like the Dutch’s Gang, possibly interrogate some O’Driscolls who say they had the score stolen off of them, and then they tell. In addition, Dutch recognizes his actions as a result of Micah’s betrayal in the end of Red Dead Redemption 2, and he retaliates by betraying him. He lost control of the gang and he just got sloppy. Like and Subscribe for more Videos. oh. Dutch and the gang then accompany Eagle Flies. IGN's Red Dead Redemption 2 (RDR2) walkthrough features guides for every main story mission, complete with Gold Medal Checklist Requirements, helpful screenshots, and tips for each of. John says that he. it's no different then when charles and arthur were beating info out of the guys who kidnapped trelawny. 257K subscribers in the RDR2 community. Dutch’s loves John in a way. Robbing Cornwall’s train in Chapter 1 (caused Cornwall to fund the Pinkertons) 33. I refuse to believe Dutch wouldn’t jump at the chance to sink Cornwall’s latest shipment of rum and sugar, humiliating his nemesis with a gigantic daiquiri in the Saint Denis harbor. r/RDR2 • Did Dutch just randomly pass by in a debt recovering side. Dead or Alive. In need of money, and with the plans and explosives stolen from the O'Driscoll's camp, the gang rides out to rob Leviticus Cornwall's private train. Even Cornwall wasn't an antagonist. Micah wins the debate, Dutch kills Cornwall, and this represents the final exclusion of Arthur's place by Dutch's side. 6 Wanted To Leave John In Prison. updated Sep 28, 2021 Who the Hell is Leviticus Cornwall is a Main Story Mission, and part of IGN’s Red Dead Redemption 2 Walkthrough. John stands off with Micah and Dutch is drawn on both. Fuck Dutch. . Once the boat arrives, listen in on Cornwall's and Milton's conversation. Cornwall train employees (optional) - Can be killed by Arthur after the robbery is complete. The Van der Linde Gang, also known as Dutch's Boys, is the main faction in the video game Red Dead Redemption II. Use A Shotgun For Close Combat. Hence why there’s a quote about this in rdr2. It can be started. Hosea is telling him not to rob cornwall in chapter 1. See full list on reddead. An anarchist Warrior Poet with a love of the nature and the frontier, Dutch saw himself not as a criminal, but a man fighting back against a corrupt system to liberate the Old West. This was likely Dutch’s attempt to create some distance between the gang and Pinkertons. And while guys like Bill and Javier are blinded by Dutchs personality, Micah prosseds spreading disagreement inside the camp, breaking the family in 2. In 1874, when Arthur was 11 years old, his father was arrested for larceny. He is also mentioned in Red Dead Online. Bitch literally pulled a knife to his throat, you can even hear him asking her to calm down and putting his hands up when she got aggressive, and he obviously couldn't shoot her because they were going stealth. rob HIS train and yet Dutch feels Cornwall is a menace that should be killed? I don’t get it unless Dutch has absolutely no plan and gives no fucks about anyone but himself. Getting involved in the Gray and Braithwaite feud (reason for Sean’s death) 24. And he also leaves the money in the chest. They find out that the vampire has been bringing the dead back to life, and he. A future, a chance. Article Contents. By Angie Harvey , Casey DeFreitas , Max Roberts , +1. Van der Linde is the last of the three targets that John Marston must capture for the Federal Government in order for them to release his. 14 votes, 24 comments. I prefer it this wayDutch shoots Cornwall, killing him. Led by Colm O'Driscoll, the gang has been around for almost as long as Dutch's Gang and the two groups have been rivals ever since. Dutch and the gang then accompany Eagle Flies. Miller was openly and publicly advocating for the tribe for a long time before they launched a new series of highly violent attacks on private. Dragon Their Feet: Dutch kills Cornwall without going through Milton first. This may be because Arthur believes that Dutch started the beef that killed his lover, for whom Dutch wants revenge, but even this is a stark, hypocritical contrast to his earlier feelings towards the Braithwaites in the aftermath of Jack's kidnapping, despite the gang starting that beef too. Arthur says in game that one time he stole from a poor man and dutch scolded him, by time rdr2 starts dutch is already on his decline with micah in his ear about cutting and running and accusing others of being rats, but before the black water massacre and in the early years of the gang, dutch definitely as a good man. 242K subscribers in the RDR2 community. As for Boss Fights, r* claims boss kills for themselves, not for the player. Issue : r/reddeadredemption. Throwing my hat into the ring with my fancasting. He oddly asks for $10,000. Abigail would be an accessory to murder by association alone. Against his father, Chief Rains Fall's wishes. He shows Colm he is loyal, and sets up Arthur to get him out of sight, to influence Dutch. I was told Guarma was meant to be more and bigger and supposedly the beginning of the mental decline of Dutch, Micah, Bill and Javier that would lead them to becoming who they became in RDR1. By Derek Garcia. Abigail kills Agent Milton John kills Dutch, Bill Williamson, Vincente De Santa, Allende, Turned in Javier Escuella and of course killed micah Jack Kills Ross. You would trust what your investigator says. After sneaking out, head back to Mr. Arthur loved him. The duo formed the Van der Linde gang together. Attempt To Bargain With Cornwall quest is completed. I think if RDR2 does a good job of anything it's illustrating that there is alot of trouble in reducing something as complicated as morality into just good or bad. He looted Cornwall Bonds, He looted Train and He had money to pack the bags and Leave and Drag John and Abigail with him. Nothing gets forgiven. 7K votes, 42 comments. Screen Rant. Then, just as John sought to do, Dutch shoots Micah allowing John to finish him off as he leaves John and Sadie alone. Around 1877, prior to the events of Red Dead Redemption 2, Arthur Morgan crossed paths with Dutch Van der Linde and Hosea Matthews, when Arthur was still very young. It is another bad decision Dutch made because Cornwall follows the gang throughout Red Dead Redemption 2 from that point on. Kill all of the soldiers, then run up the hill to where the canon is. He apparently wasn't always that way, and in the pre-RDR2, pre-Blackwater era he may have even been a good man in some respects. Eventually, your hidey-hole will catch fire, and you’ll be forced to flee out the back on foot. You must wear a bandana to hide your identity. When Dutch starts losing his mind and Arthur becomes weak, Micah starts to manipulate Dutch into horrible plans and turning him against John and Arthur. Bronte’s manor to meet back up with Dutch. Around 1877, prior to the events of Red Dead Redemption 2, Arthur Morgan crossed paths with Dutch Van der Linde and Hosea Matthews, when Arthur was still very young. On your way back, Jack will tell you. The only difference is I choose whom I kill and rob. The character felt immediately familiar. The game would take place over many many years, they'd need to get multiple actors to play each character. Follow Dutch’s lead as he tries to bargain with Cornwall. Think about it. In the long run, Leviticus Cornwall is a nasty businessman who's never afraid of going the extra mile and crossing the line, even if it. We have Milton and the Pinkterons along with Cornwall going after the gang for all the chapters. In addition, the first time Colm sees Dutch in months to years Colm remarks with a grin that Dutch "always loved the ladies" implying Dutch likely has a whoring problem. So Dutch killed Leviticus Cornwall in this video. At certain times, RDR2 's Dutch could. The original Red Dead Redemption follows John Marston as he hunts down his former gang members. As you will be in close promixity with the rest of the guards when Dutch kills Cornwall, it would be best to use a Shotgun to easily 1-shot enemies. However in the end he had some Redemption as well. we hide behind some crates and co. After his trolley accident, some believe he may have suffered from TBI (Traumatic Brain Injury). I still think of it when. With the addition of the Liars and Cheats DLC pack for Redemption, Van der Linde is also a multiplayer character model that may be selected in the 'Damnation' section of the Outfitter. The van der linde gang kills coos, and towards the end soldiers. Article Contents. For the wagon at Cornwall you can shoot the horses with an arrow from a distance and they will bolt without triggering any of the men. Mr. He already didn’t trust him. As the price on their heads continues to grow, so does the struggle to remain free. And it suits Micah's interest that either Arthur gets killed unnoticed or the whole Dutch gang gets lured into the Pinkerton's trap later on. Random camp events will often include Dutch walking up and preaching his ideologies to gatherings around. Dutch kills Micah as a means not just to get revenge – but as a way of finding redemption for himself , and maybe finding some sort of closure. !!Minor spoilers for the main story of RDR2!! So in chapter 5, when Arthur and Dutch set out to rescue Javier, they are led through the caves by that old woman, and at the end of the caves, Dutch kills her. The Pinkertons were a private army of thugs, spies, assassins, and murderers employed by people like Cornwall to brutalize and kill anyone who dared to try to form a union. Didn’t need to kill her but he did need to at the same time so we’d see his true side, good storytelling by rockstar. RDR2 Dutch—at least at the start—is charismatic, comparatively selfless, and surrounded by genuine followers and friends. . #rdr2 #reddeadredemption #arthurmorganYes, Dutch suicide himself at the end of the game. Micah only kills Ms. violence is a common method of getting info in the game, on all sides. 2. Dutch: Ha! You always were a bad liar, John! [Marston shoots the oil lantern by Dutch, catching the walkway on fire. There are two main commercial train lines in RDR2. At some point, Colm O'Driscoll is caught and sentenced to death by hanging in Saint. The Pinkertons worked for Cornwall. 2. Dutch kills Micah as a means not just to get revenge. All Dutch seemed to care about at the end of the game was getting money in whatever way possible, he didn’t care who got hurt, who he left behind, as long as he got the money he was after. •. ago Don’t think Cornwall showed up to see Dutch, Dutch found out Cornwall was in town and went to confront him. He doesn’t lose his mind. Dutch does not want to rescue John, as Dutch thinks that John. As a result, because Cornwall owns the rail transport, he would not have to accept discounts on rail travel under RDR2. They were outlaws with a code, at one time, but the actions of the money-lender Leopold Strauss were a bizarre. It ain't our fault things turned out the way they did. The gang didn’t get to Tahiti. That’s also one of the big writing problems i have with rdr2. The O'Driscoll Boys is a hostile gang encountered by the Van Der Linde Gang in Red Dead Redemption 2. By the game's narrative and he way he behaves, I'd say it's safe to assume Arthur's killed maybe a couple dozen men, generally in self defense. So at the very end of the game we know Sadie, Charles, Trelawny, Pearson, Tilly, Swanson, and Mary Beth survive. Bronte is. Rdr2: Dutch’s Plan. Arthur helps John with a plan to rustle a herd of sheep and sell them at auction in Valentine. 257K subscribers in the RDR2 community. Dutch says “you kill, I kill. After. Him saving John and Sadie was a redeemable act, but made. Mr. Red Dead Redemption 2 had an opportunity to show Dutch’s gang before it lost its ideals, but it instead revisited the same themes as the original RDR. #rdr2 #edit #shortsBut honestly, it also makes sense that Micah told Dutch to kill Cornwall. ️Thanks for watching and dont forget to SUBSCRIBE 🔔📢Join my discord server: RDR2 Npc Fights Duel Mod Created Using Map Editor. true. Denis robberies, then that’s just Dutch’s dismissive response for being caught into a big mess. Go into the store and talk to the gunsmith. And it’s where Arther finally gets to see Dutch in a similar enough situation to Blackwater in person. . ” He wasn’t really wrong. TRY GIVING IT TO HIM. As the game's narrative unravels, failure becomes the defining factor of both the Van Der Linde gang and Dutch, the enigmatic man who leads it. Especially considering rdr2 takes place at the outbreak of the Philippine American war most naval assets would be focused over there anyway. look at what dutch did to kieran for weeks; and how kieran was treated by the gang. Fitting Micah’s intentions the whole time. Arthur's loyalty to Dutch is a major driving force in the game - for the first few chapters, Dutch is a saint and a hero. Dutch kills Micah as a means not just to get revenge – but as a way of finding redemption for himself, and maybe finding some sort of closure. The Bible, it turns out, is Leviticus. Abigail was desperate to escape and can't wait forever to see gang falling apart which even didn't happen in Epilogue. I’m playing RDR2 for the the first time and am currently at the mission Who the Hell is Leviticus Cornwall? Everything was going great, I’m at the part where we’ve blown the train door open to search the private cabin, but I can’t enter the damn train because. Bell here was probably betraying the Pinkertons so he could go after the Cornwall money and after the Blackwater money. Blackwater is also the place where players first hear of Dutch's descent into evil in RDR2. Around 1878, Arthur was picked up by Dutch van der Linde and Hosea Matthews [1]. Nobody gets left behind are his words if I'm. Dutch is a talker so maybe he’s searching for the safest wat to kill Micah and get all the money out of the heavily guarded camp. In this RDR2 mission, you'll be. Hosea Matthews, master con artist, gentleman and thief, is a major character in Red Dead Redemption II . The second most violent train robbery in Red Dead Redemption 2 happens just before the gang’s transition from the ice-cold mountainside cabins to the lush and warm Horseshoe Overlook. My theory is that Micah is actually not the real traitor. Micah is a lying egoist. I hate when a story throws down my throat that a “good guy” has. Chapter 6- Beaver HollowStory Mission- Just a Social CallFor more videos like, comment, and subscribe. Dutch and Hosea were close friends for more than two decades. Speaks miles about his mindset, imo. Leopold Strauss (Confirmed Fate) - Killed by Pinkerton Agents. To start this mission, the player meets Micah Bell in Annesburg. The Dutch shown in RDR2 manages to be sympathetic, but not redeemable, and goes into and expands the Dutch in RDR1 in a believable way. Cornwall will refuse Dutch’s offer and in turn, Dutch will shoot him. Who the Hell is Leviticus Cornwall? is a mission in Red Dead Redemption 2. Dutch doesn’t even care about the $20,000 he left in the cabin. Kill Micah, kill Dutch, and tell the rest of the crew that you did it because all of shit the happened to them was there fault. It was never going to get to Tahiti. 78 votes, 13 comments. Arthur meets with John in the south part of Valentine near the auction yard. Ross would easily figure he was an unreliable ally who was only playing them after not getting Dutch and after learning that Micah founds an outlaw. They care for him and he cares for them, and we hear stories of Dutch's noble past as an American Robin Hood, protecting the weak and lifting up the downtrodden. Killin' me, it won't make it go away. . A rifle will do well here. People saying "the pinkertons are just the other side of the coin", when ignoring the fact that the Van der Linde gang has killed hundreds if not thousands of civilians and robbed probably millions of dollars from even more civilians. Go to Dutch: 7: Take dynamite from bill and set it on the carriage door: 8: Go inside the the carriage: 9: Search around the carriage for bonds: 10: Go back outside: 11: CHOICE : Kill the guards or just threaten them: 12: Go to the front of the train to start it upJohn Marston : Dutch, we all did our best for you. This action ultimately leads to Dutch making an enemy of Cornwall. Dutch and Micah should have been killed from the get go And why did he even take Dutch’s orders from the beginning of chapter 6. Dutch underestimated the Greys and it got Sean killed and it seems Hosea may have underestimated the Braithwaites which got Jack kidnapped. Yeah, exactly what I thought, thanks. . So Micah can't be the same traitor. I used to know a guy like Dutch. Occasionally they will talk about him moving it, when camps change. Dutch was more closer than ever to compete his Tahiti dream than any time before. Like it pisses me off. Hi everyone!In this video I show you guys the mission in which Dutch kills Leviticus Cornwall. Leviticus Cornwall didn't break any laws. They're not blaming Arthur for the shootout with Cornwall, they are just saying that Arthur tends to generally blame others for failures, but tries to justify himself when he fucks up. ago. He serves as the main antagonist of the game's fifth chapter. Once the boat arrives, listen in on. Heidi McCourt; an innocent girl murdered by Dutch during the Blackwater massacre. But then Dutch killed the old woman on the Island. Plus with that scene where you have to Deadeye all those goons that Cornwall. It was clear that they planned that assault together, so if he was a rat, that attack would have been a setup to capture dutch, but it wasn't. We all know GTA5's acting performance is top notch in its entirety, but this game puts acting to a whole new level. He was portrayed by John Rue. Dutch engages in an ego war with a rich and vindictive man. Dutch never actually had a plan to escape, he was just talking a big game to try and sell a dream. Arthur reacts to dutch when he kills Gloria old lady in Guarma with low and high honor. Which has an element of truth to it - remember when you rob that first Cornwall train, that Arthur is the one who connects the wires. ago. If you go back for the money, high honor will have Micah hightail out while low honor has him finish you off with a stab in the back. Dutch overrules Hosea and all the able bodied men ride out for the train. The-Solid-Smoker. Right after the speech, Arthur asks Dutch what really happened in Blackwater and Dutch says, “we missed you, son. So what the fuck? Although it wasn’t cold blood Dutch had already lost his. He wants to be respected, he wants to be The Man but as the story goes on, he loses and the more he loses, the more he feels the need to be ruthless, to take back that respect he is losing by force. This wanted notice has the face of this unwanted guest printed on it. Thanks for watching!Arthur Morgan is a central character and the primary protagonist of Red Dead Redemption 2. Follow Dutch and Micah down to the docks. Listen to Dutch's command and reach Bill. Eh, most of the time, especially during chapter 6, it happens for a story reason and therefore more engaging in that sense. This in spite of the fact that Fussar's a hilariously wealthy man who probably has something they could steal, and he has all the pretense in the world to go robbing him. The leader of the Van Der Linde gang spent the whole game becoming more treacherous and violent as time went on. Cornwall owns many of the businesses in New Hanover and its surrounding territories, but his presence is mostly known in the city of. Dutch realized he messed up bad and tried the only thing he could to make up. What Happens To Dutch If You Attempt To Loot Leviticus Cornwall In Red Dead Redemption 2? (RDR2) Cheap. I think Dutch was basically always a charismatic psychopath, but Hosea reigned in some of his more egregious insanity. The train they decide to rob belongs to Leviticus Cornwall. Dutch knows Micah betrayed him, which is why Dutch turns his back on Micah during the good ending of Red Dead Redemption 2 after Arthur Morgan dies. Also that Dutch killed Micah and as he walked away he didn’t see much point to shoot him. Decide where we go from here. In order to keep the RDR2 train schedule consistent, Cornwall would need 20 trains total. After he argues with the Pinkertons a while, and then a business partner, Dutch will pop out of hiding and. This is the type of response you’d get from those interactive fiction games from the 80’s: me: EXAMINE PIPE. The Pinkertons worked for Cornwall. Dutch van der Linde Who the Hell is Leviticus Cornwall? is a mission in Red Dead Redemption 2. [With that, he shoots Micah in the chest] Micah. Dutch is pretty unhinged from the start of rdr2. Dutch May Have Ruined Evelyn Millers Career. You'll lose honor when you constantly kill animals and let them rot without skinning/plucking, when you let them suffer for too long and bleed outs, kill farm animals like cows and sheep (especially infront of staff/owners), and domesticated animals like cats and dogs as those animals are usually considered "off limits" to the general. As a child, his mother died of unknown causes, while his father was a petty criminal and outlaw. The game’s vast and atmospheric world also provides the foundation for a brand new online multiplayer experience. You're finally meeting Mr. " 3. The pressure completely turned him. #rdr2 #arthurmorgan #rockstar #gaming #reddeadredemptionHidden dialogue from Dutch, if you shoot a bird on the way down to the Leviticus Cornwall train job. Leviticus Cornwall is the overarching antagonist of the 2018 video game Red Dead Redemption II. 4. By the start of Red Dead Redemption 2, Dutch’s schemes had become more daring in an attempt to fight back against the shrinking Wild West. Nate is mentioned in several side quests as corrupt and ineffective. I still think of it when. Bronte is a man of his word. He wasn't supposed to be an antagonist. Reply. That was the trigger, if you listen to Hosea, they all mentioned how. Dutch loves Arthur. He deserved to die for trafficking an innocent child, but was killed for bruising Dutch’s ego (although he did so in a shitty way). From Dutch's point of view he was in the right. game: YOU CANT USE DUTCH’S PIPE. Day 2 in Coulter you have Dutch and Hosea arguing about Dutch’s decision making because it makes no sense to Hosea why Dutch is doing the opposite of everything he’d said previously. Edgar Ross was. The issue if they caught him would’ve been Dutch, or god forbid Sadie, killing him before handing him over. If you go to his “hermit camp” by strawberry/monto’s rest, you can find a newspaper clipping about the Blackwater heist (150,000 dollars stolen), and Dutch’s wanted poster (1000 dollar reward) which tells me that his goal was to get Dutch arrested or killed, turn him in for clemency, and then go back and get the rest of the cash, which. He’d be Ted Kaczynski 2. I figured killing Cornwall was going to happen at the end of a difficult mission, but nope—Dutch just shoots him in a cutscene while the dude's useless guards watched, dumbly. In RDR 1, we had Edgar Ross as the main antagonist. Red Dead Redemption 2 is an epic tale of life in America’s unforgiving heartland. TremblayNHS71. Dutch meanwhile, causes the ruin of the tribe for personal gain, kills Cornwall and causes even more heat to fall on the nearby camp, basically either thinks John is the traitor or just being too defiant and leaves him to die, NEVER cares that Arthur is dying and is more concerned at his imminent lack of muscle. You're finally meeting Mr. I’ve been playing a lot of RDR2 lately, I basically wanted to experience all the side stuff as both John and Arthur, and…And the story later mirrors it with Cornwall. If Arthur has high honor, he gets to die naturally, facing the sunset of his time. 7K votes, 42 comments. They still end up in Guarma while the rest gets cornered by the Pinkertons. Since then, the two have hated each other, and ended up running their own gangs that share their rivalry. Hes a conman and a manipulator through and through. Hide behind some boxes by the docks before Cornwall and Milton’s boat arrives. S. You rob, I rob. #rdr2 #arthurmorgan #rockstar #gaming #reddeadredemptionWhile Dutch and Colm already have an uneasy relationship before, they become full blown enemies after Dutch killed Colm's brother for unknown reasons and Colm retaliates by killing Dutch's lover. Micah was a mastermind playing it all. When she demands more money and pulls a knife on Dutch, he kills her and they proceed alone. Based on how you do things in RDR2 with Dutch, like destroying an entire plantation, killing dozens of rival gangs, laying waste to towns, there's every reason to believe that Dutch could have killed John a few times along the way but preferred him to be killed by others. While the reason why RDR2's Dutch and Colm hate each other is established, that enmity isn't properly built upon in the narrative. I think Dutch was a broken man after losing. He was there in the beginning, sure he was a good guy (relatively speaking) in the beginning stages. Following the failed bank heist in St. Hosea’s relationship with Dutch was tested by their disagreements over how to make. . So even after everything Dutch did, John let him walk away. Over time, the gang gained 25 members including Arthur Morgan, John Marston, Susan Grimshaw, Mac Callander, Davey Callander, Jenny Kirk, Jack Marston, Abigail. Arthur ground his teeth and summoned the strength to sit up.